IGI vs GIA: Which Diamond Certification Is Better?
jewellery

IGI vs GIA: Which Diamond Certification Is Better?

By Max Roberts / April 16, 2025

When it comes to buying a diamond, whether mined or lab-grown, certification matters. Two of the most prominent gemological laboratories in the world are the International Gemological Institute (IGI) and the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). While both are highly regarded, they differ in grading standards, scope, and perception in the diamond industry.

In this article, we’ll explore the key differences between IGI and GIA, covering their grading methodologies, credibility, cost implications, and what you should consider when choosing between the two.

What Is Diamond Certification?

Before diving into the IGI vs GIA comparison, it’s essential to understand what a diamond certificate is. Also known as a grading report, a diamond certificate is a document issued by a gemological laboratory detailing the specifications of a diamond. This typically includes:

  • Carat weight

  • Cut grade

  • Color grade

  • Clarity grade

  • Polish and symmetry

  • Fluorescence

  • Measurements and proportions

This report is crucial for determining a diamond’s value and authenticity.

Overview of IGI and GIA

GIA (Gemological Institute of America)

  • Founded: 1931

  • Headquarters: Carlsbad, California, USA

  • Known for: Developing the 4Cs (Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat) grading system

  • Industry Reputation: Considered the most stringent and consistent lab in the world

IGI (International Gemological Institute)

  • Founded: 1975

  • Headquarters: Antwerp, Belgium

  • Known for: Certifying both natural and lab-grown diamonds at scale

  • Industry Reputation: Popular among retailers and manufacturers for fast turnaround and affordability

IGI vs GIA: Key Differences

Feature GIA IGI
Founded 1931 1975
Global Recognition High Moderate to High
Strictness in Grading Very Strict Slightly More Lenient
Reports for Lab-Grown Diamonds Yes (since 2007, updated in 2019) Yes (early adopter)
Turnaround Time Slower Faster
Cost of Certification Higher Lower
Retailer Preference High-end jewelers prefer GIA IGI more common with lab-grown

1. Grading Consistency and Accuracy

GIA is often regarded as the gold standard. Its grading reports are considered the most consistent and trustworthy, especially for natural diamonds. Retailers and consumers alike know that a GIA “D” color or “VS1” clarity is strictly graded.

IGI, while respected, has been known to grade diamonds slightly more generously. For instance, a diamond graded as “VS1” by IGI may receive a “VS2” or even “SI1” grade from GIA. This doesn’t mean IGI is inaccurate—it simply means their grading scale may lean toward leniency.

2. Lab-Grown Diamond Certification

Here’s where things get interesting.

IGI was one of the first laboratories to certify lab diamonds on a large scale. As a result, many jewelers and brands offering lab-grown diamonds choose IGI for its speed and affordability.

GIA was slower to enter the lab-grown space but has since revamped its lab-grown grading reports (in 2019) to resemble those issued for natural diamonds, using full 4Cs grading instead of generic terms like “colorless” or “slightly included.”

Bottom Line:

  • IGI dominates the lab-grown diamond space (especially with CVD and HPHT stones).

  • GIA is catching up and is now a trusted option for high-end lab-grown certification.

3. Turnaround Time and Cost

Time and money are significant factors for retailers.

  • IGI typically offers faster turnaround times—sometimes within a few days.

  • GIA, known for meticulous grading, may take longer to issue a report.

In terms of pricing:

  • IGI is more affordable, making it attractive to online retailers and those dealing in lower-margin products.

  • GIA’s higher certification fees reflect its global prestige and reputation.

4. Market Perception and Resale Value

If you’re looking to resell a diamond, GIA-certified stones usually fetch a better price, especially for natural diamonds. Buyers have more confidence in GIA’s consistency.

IGI-certified diamonds are more accepted in lab-grown markets, but resale values may not be as high or predictable compared to GIA-certified stones.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose GIA if:

  • You’re buying a natural diamond

  • You want the strictest grading

  • You’re concerned about resale value

  • You prefer higher market trust

Choose IGI if:

  • You’re buying a lab-grown diamond

  • You want a faster and cheaper certification

  • You’re purchasing from a retailer that primarily uses IGI

Are IGI and GIA Certifications Interchangeable?

Not entirely. A diamond graded by IGI and another by GIA with similar specs might differ in value and price. For example, if an IGI certificate claims a diamond is G color and VS2 clarity, it may be graded as H color and SI1 clarity by GIA. This can affect the price significantly.

Final Thoughts

Both IGI and GIA play crucial roles in the diamond industry. While GIA remains the benchmark for natural diamonds due to its uncompromising grading standards, IGI is an excellent choice for lab-grown diamonds, offering reliable certification at a more accessible price point.

Ultimately, the best certification depends on your budget, the type of diamond you’re buying, and what matters most to you—be it investment value, certification speed, or affordability.

You may also like